The short answer

Organizations usually choose independent design agencies for four reasons: senior people are directly involved in the work; advice is impartial because there is no platform or software to sell; research, design and software come together in one small team; and the relationship can continue for years with the same people. On the other hand, for multi-country programmes that need hundreds of people, larger structures can be a better fit.

What is an independent design agency?

An independent design agency is one that doesn’t belong to an international agency network, a holding company or a software vendor, and makes its decisions with its own founders and team. Independence isn’t a matter of size: an independent agency can be small or employ dozens of people. What matters is who it answers to and what it is trying to sell.

Why do organizations choose independent agencies?

Senior people stay on the work

In large structures, the senior team that presents the pitch is often not the team that does the work. In independent agencies, founders and senior team members are usually directly involved in the day-to-day work of the project. The organization knows who makes the decisions and can reach them directly.

Advice is impartial

An agency that isn’t tied to a software vendor or a particular platform can recommend whichever technology is right for the organization. This matters most for long-term investments: the choice of platform decides how a product can evolve for years.

Disciplines sit at the same table

In digital transformation projects, the biggest losses happen in hand-offs between disciplines: researchers deliver a report, designers deliver screens, developers reinterpret both. In independent agencies, research, strategy, design and software usually run in the same small team, at the same table. Decisions carry from one stage to the next without getting lost.

The relationship gains continuity

Digital products keep evolving after launch. Continuing that evolution with the same people for years means the organization doesn’t have to explain itself again each time. With small, stable teams, independent agencies can keep that continuity more easily.

Speed of decisions and adaptation

In an independent agency, there are few layers to go through to approve a proposal. When the scope changes, an unexpected technical problem appears or the organization’s priorities shift, the agency can adapt quickly.

Working alongside the organization’s team

Independent agencies are often used to working with an organization’s in-house team rather than replacing it, handing over design systems, research methods and documentation and growing the organization’s own capability along the way.

When is an independent agency not the right choice?

It isn’t right for every project. Other structures can be a better fit when there is:

  • A need for very large capacity. Programmes run in many countries at once, with teams of hundreds.
  • Organizational transformation. If the core of the work is restructuring, processes and people rather than a digital product, management consultancies are stronger.
  • A decision tied to one platform. If the organization has chosen a particular enterprise software package and the work is largely its implementation, that software’s specialist implementation partners may be a better fit.

Questions to ask before working with an independent agency

The strengths of independent agencies can also become risks if the right questions aren’t asked:

  • Capacity: How does the team grow during the busiest periods of the project?
  • Key-person dependency: If a key person leaves, how is knowledge kept? Where are the documentation and design system held?
  • Continuity: How long has the agency been operating, and what are its longest client relationships?
  • Technical scope: Can it take on software, integration and maintenance as well as design?
  • Enterprise processes: How has it met procurement, information security and data protection requirements before?
  • Ownership: Who will own the source code, design files and documentation?

We have gathered the full set of criteria for choosing an agency in a separate article.

Hybrid models

In most organizations, the best results come from a combination rather than a single choice: a management consultancy leads the strategic transformation, an independent agency handles the research, design and software of the digital product, and an in-house team that grows stronger over time runs the product day to day. The independent agency’s role in this model is to hand methods and knowledge over to the in-house team as well as building the product.

In short

  • Independence is about who an agency answers to and what it sells, not its size.
  • Organizations choose independent agencies for senior attention, impartial advice, disciplines working together and continuity.
  • For very large capacity, organizational transformation or a single platform’s implementation, other structures can fit better.
  • Asking about capacity, key-person dependency and ownership up front reduces the risks of working with an independent agency.

Efabrika has worked as an independent experience design agency in İstanbul since 2006. We explain how we work in our approach and on our about page; if you’d like to talk about a project, get in touch.